Shepherd's Pie Ingredient Substitutes
Missing an ingredient for your Shepherd's Pie? Find the best substitute for every common Shepherd's Pie ingredient below — with exact ratios and tips specific to this recipe.
Choose an Ingredient to Substitute
Agave Substitute
Best: Maple Syrup
All-Purpose Flour Substitute
Best: Whole Wheat Flour
Almond Extract Substitute
Best: Vanilla Extract
Apple Cider Vinegar Substitute
Best: White Wine Vinegar
Arrowroot Powder Substitute
Best: Cornstarch
Avocado Oil Substitute
Best: Light Olive Oil
Baking Powder Substitute
Best: Baking Soda + Cream of Tartar
Baking Soda Substitute
Best: Baking Powder
Balsamic Vinegar Substitute
Best: Red Wine Vinegar with a touch of brown sugar
Beef Broth Substitute
Best: Beef Stock
Bread Flour Substitute
Best: All-Purpose Flour
Brown Sugar Substitute
Best: Dark Corn Syrup
Butter Substitute
Best: Margarine
Buttermilk Substitute
Best: Milk + Lemon Juice
Cake Flour Substitute
Best: All-Purpose Flour with Cornstarch
Chicken Broth Substitute
Best: Vegetable Broth
Cocoa Powder Substitute
Best: Unsweetened Baking Chocolate
Coconut Oil Substitute
Best: Unsalted Butter
Cornstarch Substitute
Best: Potato Starch
Cream Cheese Substitute
Best: Greek Yogurt
Dark Chocolate Substitute
Best: Unsweetened Cocoa Powder
Egg Substitute
Best: Flaxseed Meal
Fish Sauce Substitute
Best: Soy Sauce with a touch of Worcestershire Sauce
Garlic Substitute
Best: Garlic Powder
Granulated Sugar Substitute
Best: Honey
Greek Yogurt Substitute
Best: Sour Cream
Heavy Cream Substitute
Best: Whole Milk and Butter
Honey Substitute
Best: Maple Syrup
Lemon Juice Substitute
Best: White Wine Vinegar
Maple Syrup Substitute
Best: Honey
Olive Oil Substitute
Best: Canola Oil
Onion Substitute
Best: Leek
Powdered Sugar Substitute
Best: Granulated Sugar
Sour Cream Substitute
Best: Greek Yogurt
Soy Sauce Substitute
Best: Tamari
Vanilla Extract Substitute
Best: Vanilla Bean Paste
Vegetable Broth Substitute
Best: Mushroom Broth
Vegetable Oil Substitute
Best: Canola Oil
White Vinegar Substitute
Best: Lemon Juice
Whole Milk Substitute
Best: Half-and-Half
Worcestershire Sauce Substitute
Best: Soy Sauce and Apple Cider Vinegar Blend
Yeast Substitute
Best: Baking Powder
Quick Reference: Best Substitutes for Shepherd's Pie
| Ingredient | Best Substitute |
|---|---|
| 🌵 Agave | Maple Syrup |
| 🌾 All-Purpose Flour | Whole Wheat Flour |
| 🌰 Almond Extract | Vanilla Extract |
| 🍎 Apple Cider Vinegar | White Wine Vinegar |
| 🌿 Arrowroot Powder | Cornstarch |
| 🥑 Avocado Oil | Light Olive Oil |
| 🧪 Baking Powder | Baking Soda + Cream of Tartar |
| 🧪 Baking Soda | Baking Powder |
| 🍇 Balsamic Vinegar | Red Wine Vinegar with a touch of brown sugar |
| 🍲 Beef Broth | Beef Stock |
| 🍞 Bread Flour | All-Purpose Flour |
| 🟫 Brown Sugar | Dark Corn Syrup |
| 🧈 Butter | Margarine |
| 🥛 Buttermilk | Milk + Lemon Juice |
| 🎂 Cake Flour | All-Purpose Flour with Cornstarch |
| 🍲 Chicken Broth | Vegetable Broth |
| 🍫 Cocoa Powder | Unsweetened Baking Chocolate |
| 🥥 Coconut Oil | Unsalted Butter |
| 🌽 Cornstarch | Potato Starch |
| 🧀 Cream Cheese | Greek Yogurt |
| 🍫 Dark Chocolate | Unsweetened Cocoa Powder |
| 🥚 Egg | Flaxseed Meal |
| 🐟 Fish Sauce | Soy Sauce with a touch of Worcestershire Sauce |
| 🧄 Garlic | Garlic Powder |
| 🍬 Granulated Sugar | Honey |
| 🥛 Greek Yogurt | Sour Cream |
| 🫗 Heavy Cream | Whole Milk and Butter |
| 🍯 Honey | Maple Syrup |
| 🍋 Lemon Juice | White Wine Vinegar |
| 🍁 Maple Syrup | Honey |
| 🫒 Olive Oil | Canola Oil |
| 🧅 Onion | Leek |
| ❄️ Powdered Sugar | Granulated Sugar |
| 🥛 Sour Cream | Greek Yogurt |
| 🫙 Soy Sauce | Tamari |
| 🌿 Vanilla Extract | Vanilla Bean Paste |
| 🥦 Vegetable Broth | Mushroom Broth |
| 🫙 Vegetable Oil | Canola Oil |
| 🫙 White Vinegar | Lemon Juice |
| 🥛 Whole Milk | Half-and-Half |
| 🫙 Worcestershire Sauce | Soy Sauce and Apple Cider Vinegar Blend |
| 🍄 Yeast | Baking Powder |